I've decided that trades are something that really interest me, so I'm going to cover all of the trading deadline deals starting with today. First on the agenda is the seemingly minor David Bell trade. Tomorrow I'll give an analysis over the Carlos Lee/Coco deal, and the Betemit/Baez one. Plus I'll try to get any other deal that comes along.
Phillies trade: David Bell
Brewers trade: Wilfrido Laureano
Wilfrido Laurenao is a 22 year old A-ball relief pitcher with a 4.10 ERA in 29 games this year. I've heard many places call him an average A prospect. Now I apologize to Laurenao's parents for my bluntness, but he is much worse then an average A ball prospect. Relief pitchers in the low minor leagues very rarely amount to anything, since a player who a team feels will amount to something will either be a starter to get a lot of innings to ready themselves for the majors, or in rare instances be a closer so they can be in pressure situations. Sure he has a decent strikeout rate (62 K's in 63 2/3rds IP) but his walk rate is below average (36) and his amount of homeruns given up is frightening for such a low amount of innings (8). If Laureneo ever makes it to the majors I will be shocked. He is organizational filler, nothing more.
Bell is what he is... a below average 3B with a little power (very little), terrible contact, an average eye, and a 4.5 million dollar salary. He's a decent backup, but if he's starting on your team then it's a pretty good sign your team isn't going anywhere.
Well the Phillies got what they want. By trading David Bell they'll save over a million dollars. The problem for the Phillies comes from who replaces Bell in the lineup, as there are no top prospects in the minors waiting for the callup. Early reports say that Abraham Nunez will take his place. Judging from previous years, Nunez won't even be able to get close to match Bell's mediocre numbers. So if Nunez becomes the starter the Phillies would regret the loss of production from Bell.
The other option in the Phillies team is a career AAAA guy named Chris Coste. Sure his primary position is catcher, but he has played 3rd base before in the minors so he should be in the discussion. Even though he never really has impressed in the minors, he has an interesting past where he spent four years in the Northern Independent League before ever even getting signed by a team. When he finally got signed by a big league team he performed relatively well in AA action, of course by then he was 27 years old. Since then he has bounced from the Indians, to the Red Sox, to the Brewers, and finally to the Phillies. Looking at the numbers of the 33 year-old journeyman it's obvious that he should be given the chance over Nunez. He's got some power, he actually has a decent average and his eye looks about average. I'm not saying he would be great if getting a job, but I think the Phillies at least have David Bell Jr. on their hands... even though this guy is older then Bell.
With the Brewers all I can say is that this trade must imply either Koskie's or Week's injury is much more serious then they've let on, or they just felt they had to get the insurance in case something does go wrong with their injury recovery. Well for backup insurance, Bell was a pretty decent acquisition that costed nothing except the money it takes to pay him. It's just the Brewers better hope they don't have to use him anymore then a typical bench player.
Final VerdictBrewers:
7.5 Riley Points - Insurance for nothing except money. Nothing wrong with that.
Phillies: If Nunez gets the job...
4 Riley Points - save money but will actually miss Bell's production.
If Coste wins the job...
8.5 Riley Points - save money and replace Bell with his twin who has a history that should make a couple of interesting minutes on Sportscenter.
Sure this won't send either team to the playoffs but this is definitely a deal that can help both teams. If only the Phillies take the risky choice instead of the known mediocrity. Come on Phillies... do the right thing.
--Riley Points are given on a scale of 1-10 with 1 being a terrible trade with no redeemable qualities, and 10 will be an amazing deal that has no negative quality to the trade... of course this isn't certain because every trade can have something go wrong... (or go right) that nobody could expect--